This summary is based on the California Court of Appeal’s published decision in Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, filed November 13, 2026. The court addressed an appeal from VXI Global Solutions, LLC (Global) challenging a trial court order denying its motion to compel arbitration of employee Tracie Bennett’s claims arising from her employment.
The court affirmed the trial court’s decision, holding that the arbitration agreement Bennett signed was both procedurally and substantively unconscionable and that its unconscionable aspects could not be cured by severance. The court emphasized that the agreement was “permeated with illegality” and rejected efforts to rewrite or limit its terms to save it from unenforceability.
Bennett was hired as an account associate in February 2023 and received a new hire packet including an arbitration agreement and confidentiality agreement, which she signed without consulting an attorney. The arbitration agreement required Bennett to arbitrate all claims or controversies, including those unrelated to her employment and continuing indefinitely after her employment ended. It also broadly defined the “Company” to include Global’s past and present employees, officers, and affiliates, extending the agreement’s reach to numerous third-party beneficiaries.
The court applied California law and the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and found:
- The arbitration agreement was a contract of adhesion, creating a low degree of procedural unconscionability due to the standardized and nonnegotiable nature of the contract.
- Substantive unconscionability existed in several provisions, notably:
- The unreasonably broad scope, requiring arbitration of all claims “whether or not those claims or controversies arise out of [Bennett’s] employment”.
- The unlimited duration, as the agreement survived termination of employment and could only be revoked by mutual written agreement.
- A lopsided application favoring Global and third-party beneficiaries, who could compel arbitration without reciprocal obligations.
- The confidentiality agreement’s injunctive relief provisions allowing Global to obtain injunctions without proving irreparable harm.
- The nonsolicitation clause, which restrained Bennett from soliciting Global’s employees for one year post-employment without limiting the restriction to illegal means, violating California’s statutory ban on unreasonable restraints of trade.
The court concluded that the arbitration and confidentiality agreements should be construed together as they were executed as part of the same transaction and relate to similar subject matters.
Because multiple unconscionable provisions were intertwined, the court found the overall arbitration agreement permeated with unfairness and illegality. It determined that severing the problematic terms without rewriting the agreement—which courts are not permitted to do—was impossible. Accordingly, refusal to enforce the arbitration agreement was appropriate.
“Because the agreement is permeated with illegality and its unconscionability cannot be cured through severance, we conclude the trial court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to enforce the agreement.”
The court also addressed the argument that its unconscionability analysis was preempted by the FAA. It reaffirmed that the FAA allows state courts to apply general contract defenses like unconscionability to arbitration agreements so long as these do not single out arbitration for disfavored treatment.
Editorial: Potential Impact
This decision signals California appellate courts’ willingness to closely scrutinize employment arbitration agreements with broad or indefinite scopes, especially where terms impose lifelong arbitration obligations and extend to broad third-party beneficiaries. By emphasizing the inability to cure unconscionable provisions through severance without rewriting the contract, the court underscores the importance of carefully tailored arbitration agreements that avoid overreach and unfairness.
Employers using standardized arbitration agreements may need to consider narrowing scope clauses to claims arising directly from employment and clearly limiting the duration to avoid indefinite obligations. The decision also highlights how related agreements, such as confidentiality or nonsolicitation clauses, may affect the enforceability of arbitration agreements when construed together.
Though the ruling is limited to its factual and procedural context and interprets California law, it may influence how employer-drafted arbitration contracts are structured to withstand unconscionability challenges. It also reinforces that state law contract principles, including protections against unfair restraints of trade, continue to operate alongside federal arbitration law.
Source: Read the full decision on CourtListener
Court: California Court of Appeal | Docket: B346763 | Date filed: 2026-11-13
This article was generated automatically from a public court record and is provided for informational purposes only. It is not legal advice. Refer to the linked source document for the authoritative text of the decision.